MilitaryHistoryOnline.com Home   Genealogy   Forums   Search   Contact
Search
Amazon:
Keywords:
MHO Home
MHO Home
 Ancient
 Medieval
 17th Century
 18th Century
 19th Century
 American Civil War
 World War I
 World War II
 Korea
 Vietnam
 20th - 21st Century


 Write for MHO
 Search MHO
 Civil War Genealogy Database
 Privacy Policy
 MilitaryGaming.com

Member Articles
Alfred Thayer Mahan: Advocate for Seapower
From Small Causes, Great Events Pt3
Into the Special Forces: Rudi Horvath
American Airborne Units in WWII
Czechoslovak Exile Units of WWII
The Battle of Pinkie Cleugh
The Fulda Gap
Published works on WWII OOB for land forces
Flying Tiger, Hidden Eagle
SAARF – Special Allied Airborne Recon Force
Force at la Difensa
The Third Battle of Megiddo
The Third Battle of Anchialus
Sabotaging Hitler’s Heavy Water
Return of Rogers' Rangers
Soviet Offensive in the Arctic
The Siege of Mazagan, 1562
T.E. Lawrence and Asymmetric Warfare
The Borinqueneers: 65th Inf Regt
Americans in the Boer War
Logistics and Western Way of War
The Failure of Strategic Bombing
Dutch Harbor: Unraveling of Japan’s Pacific Strategy
The Third Day at Gettysburg
From Small Causes, Great Events Pt2
Ed Ramsey, 26th Cav Reg (Philippine Scouts)
Response to Everett L. Wheeler’s review
Marching to Timbuktu
US Army in Czechoslovakia '45: An Operational Overview
Strategic Culture of the IJN
Battles of Luneville: September 1944
Adolphus, Genius of Sweden
Visual Guide to US Fleet Subs Pt 1
British Infantry Tactics in WWI
Lodge Act Soldier
The Sharif and the Sultan of Fishermen
The Fate of the Kido Butai
From Small Causes, Great Events
Charge of the Polish Light Horse at Somosierra
Second Samnite War Phase 2
Air Recon in WWII
The Roman Disaster at Adrianople
Cyberwar in the 21st Century
Ninety Five Theses and the Revolution
Bullets Quickly Write New Tactics
Second Lebanon War
WWII Veteran Interview - Walter Holy
The influence of Neurotechnology on Just War
Turning East: Hitler's only option
Fury, Fumaroles and Brimstone
Resupply Operations to Malta, 1942
Son of an Artilleryman Follows Father’s Footsteps
Colonel Patrick O'Rorke
Plague of the Spanish Lady
Cairo’s Fortress on the Mountain
WWII Veteran Interview
Why Arnhem?
Hell Ship - From the Philippines to Japan
The Battleship USS Oregon
SMS Dresden's War
Air Recon in WWI
US Army in Czechoslovakia '45 to '48
Jewish Resistance in WWII
Betrayed by a Mason?
Angel of Mons
Who Killed the Red Baron?
Armenian Warriors, Japanese Samurai
Benedict Arnold in Canada
D-Day Gate Crasher
Vets Tell All -- He Listens
308th Infantry during Argonne
Battle for the Seaports
British Officers and Gentlemen
Banzai Attack on Attu
End of the Battle of the Java Sea
Texas National Guard in WWII
How Arnhem was Lost
The War between Norway and Sweden 1808
Armenians in Strategikon
Suez Canal Guerrillas
Birth of a PMC
Sir Thomas Stukeley
Cuban Missile Crisis
Saga of Ormoc Bay
Memorials Past and Future
Second Samnite War
Korea: Study In Unpreparedness
Intelligence in the Philippine Insurrection
Stanley at Shiloh: A Improbable 'Indiana Jones'
The Green Beret Affair: A Factual Review
Silent Service of the Pacific
USS Wahoo
Gulf War Press Mobilization
Special Order 191: Ruse of War?
Mexican Revolution and US Intervention 1910-1917
Polish Cavalry: A Military Myth Dispelled
Confucian Martial Culture
Operation Market Garden
War in So. Italy 342-327 BC
Avoiding World War III
Legacy of WWII Sub Veterans
Chosin Reservoir
Lausdell Crossroads
Asian Art of War
Kasserine Pass
Gonzales: Crucible of Texas Revolution
Sheridan's Southern Plains Campaign
Milvern Harrell: Dawson Massacre
Arnhem Startline
Roman Army Field Manual
15th Illinois Infantry
Bushido: Valor of Deceit
British Lion Polish Eagle
British Offensive Operations
Decisions of Disaster: Jutland 1916
Endgame in Flanders, 1918
Constantinople - Citadel at the Gate
Bacon's Rebellion
First Samnite War
Phoenix Reven
USS Charger
English Way of War
Roman Expedition into Dacia
Sir Winston Churchill
Chinese Support for Vietnam
Fannin's Regiment
Battle of Poyang Lake
German Commerce Raiders
Indecisiveness of Battles
8th New Hampshire Infantry
American Stubbornness at Rimling
Mexican American War
The OSS in Greece
China Marines
Pompey and Ancient Piracy
The Northwest Army
MacArthur and the Cavalry
Naval Infantry in US Military History
Strategy of Blitzkrieg
Giuseppe Garibaldi
Breaking Seelow Heights
Soviet Experience in Afhanistan
Apocalypse Then
American Revolution
Western Way of War
American Way of War
The Battle Tannenberg
The Rape of Nanking
The Kitona Operation
Solferino: Slaughter and Rebirth
Siege of Osaka
Confederate Railroad
Shenandoah Campaign
Fredericksburg Campaign
Commanders and Censors
Tet Offensive
Battle of Lundy's Lane
Battle of Paris
Flip Side of Containment
Small Battle: Big Implications
Unconventional Warfare
Harris Class APA
Aerial Defense of East Indies
Sun Tzu and Overland Campaign
ACW Military Theory
Why the Bulge Didn't Break
MacArthur: 1931-1935
American Forces in WWII
Shadow Warriors
Bear River Massacre
Reflections on Iran
The Success of Napoleon
Battle of Surigao Strait
Cuba's Operation Carlotta
Panzer Brigades
Adolf Eichmann
Battle of Great Bridge
Seapower in the Yuan Dynasty
Frederick: Battle of Leuthen
Nutmeggers on Antietam Creek
Nathan Bedford Forrest
G. Washington and J. Monroe
Mao and Giap On Guerrilla Warfare
Interview of a WWII Veteran
Stephen Douglas and Popular Sovereignty
The "Green Beret Affair"
The Start: Ft. Necessity
Napoleon's Campaign of 1809
Clark Field, Philippines
Winter Warfare
The Great Retreat
The Raid on Thurso, 1649
The City Point Explosion
Capture of USS President
Operation Rusty: The Gehlen-U.S. Army Connection
The Hundred Years War: An Analysis
Why France Lost the Seven Years' War
A Cold War Retrospective
Dalton to Atlanta-Sherman vs. Johnston
The Fenian Raids
Military History of War of 1812
Blowback
Hitler, Germany's Worst General
A Path Across the Rhine: Remagen
Failures during the Spanish Civil War
Surface Actions of World War II
Austerlitz: Napoleon Makes His Own Luck
MacArthur's Failures in the Philippines
The Battle of Cowpens
The Failures at Spion Kop
Combatants in Black Hawk War
Japan's Monster Sub
Britain's Participation Justified?
Popski's Private Army
The Maple Leaf Adventure
An Odd Way to View WWII
America's Paradoxical Trinity
The Soviet Formula for Success
Basic Counter-Insurgency
The Onin War
The Battle of Pea Ridge
Tunisian Army in Crimean War
Japan's TA-Operation
The Cambodian Incursion
Hitler Youth: An Effective Organization
Dien Bien Phu: A Battle Assessment
After Midway: The Fates of the Warships
Lafayette Escadrille Pilots
Governor Kieft's Personal War
Barbarossa: Strategic Miscalculation
History of 138th PA
Giuseppe Garibaldi
The Story of a "Go Devil"
Long Range Desert Group
Island of Death
The Caterpillar Club
Foundation of Modern Army Regiments
One of Ten Thousand
The Design Was Not Passed On
Subverting the Sultan
John Paul Jones and Asymetric Warfare
The Liberation of Czechoslovakia 1945
Dien Bien Phu 50 Years Later
The Battle of Mogadishu
"A Time of Testing": Battle for Hue
StuIG at Stalingrad
Only the Admirals were Happy
Bicycle Blitzkrieg - Singapore
What if?
The Effect of Industrialization
Tanks in the Garden of Eden
Early Texas Military History
Office of Strategic Services
Barbarossa
The Mitrailleuse
The Grande Armee of 1812 in Russia
Role of Artillery in Korea
Thermopylae, Balaklava and Kokoda
Battle of Mantinea
Pearl Harbor
American Revolution in the Caribbean
The French Campaign of 1859
The Battle of Midway
The Battle of Franklin
Waffen SS - Birth of the Elite
Want of a Nail: Confederate Ironclads
Changing Generalship and Tactics
Nomonhan and Okinawa
Der Bund Deutscher Mädel
Boudicca: What Do We Really Know?
Rulers of the World: The Hitler Youth
The Master's Misstep
The Order of St. Lazarus
Breakout From the Hedgerows
St. Etienne: US 36th Division in WWI
Yalta
Memories of D-Day
Life and Death of the 10th NJ Infantry
The Raid on Dieppe

More Archived Articles...

Tony Welch Interviews
Walter Holy
Fury, Fumaroles and Brimstone
Son of an Artilleryman Follows Father’s Footsteps
D-Day Gate Crasher
Vets Tell All -- He Listens

Ads by Google



The Art of the Interview
The Art of the Interview - Serious Sit-downs with WWII Veterans
As Remembered by Tony Welch

Transcribed audio recording by Adrian Chalmers* (4/2/2011)

You’ve been doing World War Two oral histories now --- how many years?

“Well…in a serious way, since around 1973. I was the first one in my family to serve in the military since the Civil War – a span of ninety years. Back in the mid-fifties I worked in the same Eighth Naval District headquarters office as Howard Gilmore’s widow. Her husband skippered the submarine Growler and was the first sub sailor to be awarded the Medal of Honor posthumously. Mrs. Gilmore held an administrative job with the Navy – guaranteed employment for life. She told me this story and I’m sure that’s when I first got hooked. She began by saying she was personally responsible for having sent hundreds of mules to a watery grave. Mules? Mules in the Navy? Well…I was all ears. It turns out these mules were rounded up during the war from sharecropper farms throughout the southern states. Mrs. Gilmore was the project manager and co-ordinated various civilian contractors whose job it was to purchase, assemble and arrange the mules’ transportation to various war zones in the Pacific where they’d serve as infantry pack animals. The loaded merchant ships would sail down the Mississippi from New Orleans, enter the gulf and then -- wham! Three cargo vessels in all, each one torpedoed and sunk months apart by German U-boats. Something like 800 mules sent straight to the bottom. So….first her husband, wounded topside in a surface engagement and lost overboard when the sub submerged. Then her mules – sunk by enemy subs. And then the final blow -- Growler sunk with the entire crew in 1944. Think of it – the same men her husband sacrificed his life for – now also lost. Learning about this sequence of events left me intrigued – and all the more so because the story teller was a lady who’d suffered so many slings and arrows. I also got to know a couple Navy lifers, CPOs nearing retirement age. I set about picking their brains. One of them, a coxswain, told me he drove a landing craft loaded with GIs on D-Day. He caught a chunk of artillery shrapnel that shattered two ribs and punctured a lung. He then proceeded to show me the jagged scar on his back, while drawing my attention to the fact that the scar was roughly shaped like the letter ‘u’. Which it was. The chief then proclaimed that the ‘u’ stood for Utah – as in Utah beach, which is where he was wounded. Well…. I came straight up off my chair! I asked him if I could touch it. Hey– how many people ever get a chance to touch a genuine war wound? He kind of stared at me for a long moment and then replied: ‘Just be damn quick about it.’ (laughs) So anyway, now you know how I became addicted.”

When you interview a vet, what’s the preferred setting? Is it important to create a certain atmosphere?

“Well, let me just say….and this came as a surprise…there’s scores of instructional pamphlets and even books on the subject of how to conduct an oral interview. I only recently discovered them on the internet. The majority are detailed and often very fussy – like what clothes to wear to the interview. A lot of it reads like a psychology course – using certain inflections in your voice – learning to recognize facial expressions and their meanings. Reading body language, that kind of thing. Like a detective interrogating a suspect. Or a personnel manager interviewing a potential employee. Always follow a certain formula to fit a given situation. It’s not that what’s offered isn’t useful – it’s just that there’s way too much of it to absorb. I can’t get into all that or I’d become totally focused on myself. For me, keeping the subject focused is more important than anything. Otherwise, you end up with a plate full of scrambled eggs. As for location, I’ve done interviews in backyard patios and living rooms—they’re usually more at ease in familiar surroundings. I interviewed one fellow while he soaked in his hot tub. Funny thing being -- the guy was a boiler tender who built up steam on the battleship Nevada so it was able to get underway amidst all those falling bombs on December 7. Get the connection? – boiler room, hot tub? And one in an aviation museum, where I interviewed a Mustang pilot. We’re both sitting under the wing of a Me-109 – eight of which he’d shot down in combat. I’ve always been a sucker when it comes to irony – the more irony there is, the more alluring the story and the more I’m attracted to it. I don’t know why, but warfare seems to be a breeding ground for the ironic. Like the retired sailors who answered a classified ad in a Navy publication that sought contact with crew members of a certain submarine. This was like 35 years after the war ended. Turned out to be a former Japanese soldier aboard a troop transport that was sunk by the same sub – and now a wealthy businessman. The guy wasn’t looking for revenge – he just wanted to prove that former enemies could be friends once they got to know one another. He even got the captain of the sub to show up. Three different social gatherings in all – and everything paid for by the host whom they gave a good dunking to in the South China Sea years before. There was a full regiment of Jap troops aboard that transport, of whom 515 drowned. That’s a heap of forgiveness, I’d say.”

I would assume you try to establish a certain level of trust with your subjects. You can’t just start off…

“Oh…you’re absolutely right. I learned a valuable lesson early on – how to avoid being shouted at. I begin by telling them at the outset that at some point during the interview, odds are they’ll be shouting at me. I mean, really shouting. This always gets their undivided attention, followed by solemn assurances from them that nothing of the sort will ever happen. At this point I explain that when I apply due diligence and begin checking up on certain historical details and events, chances are I’ll discover that they don’t jive with what I’ve been told in the interview. Dates, places, sequential time-lines, after-action reports -- whatever. I even predict what they’re going to shout: “WHO THE HELL WAS THERE – YOU OR ME!” That makes them really sit up straight. I then present written documentary evidence proving that errors were made – here, here and here. The point of all this, I add, is to ensure accuracy. Otherwise, we’ll both be viewed as a couple slipshod nincompoops. There’s always somebody out there in the reading audience who’s going to pick up on a mistake. I’ve found this approach to be a good icebreaker. Fading memories simply can’t be trusted – but there’s no shame in that. I tell them we just have to be prepared to deal with it when and if it happens. And so now I’m on his side and suddenly trustworthy. He can relax a little, knowing I’ll take the time and trouble to get it right. I like to think that being a hard-nosed fact-checker is my own small way of honoring these men. Make certain it’s accurate – I owe them that much in return for their time and patience. And on that rare occasion when an issue can’t be resolved, just drop it. After all, we’re not here to do battle – only to talk about it. Oh – and always offer to let the subject make any editorial changes to the finished copy before publishing it. That’s helped to close the deal more than once – though I have to add, I’ve been surprised how often they prefer to see it for the first time as a published article. I think it’s a bit like sneaking a peak at your Christmas presents under the tree – why jump the gun and spoil the fun. The anticipation of seeing the story for the first time along with all the other readers seems to be a powerful attraction.”

How do you get your subjects to reveal their innermost thoughts and emotions as they relate to certain remembered events? What I’m getting at here – how deep do you dig? Or maybe dare to dig is a better phrase.

“There’s lots of verbal camouflage, that’s for sure. What I’ve yet to hear is anyone actually use the word fear. As in -- afraid. And yet overcoming fear is what drives armed conflict. The vets I’ve encountered have deleted the word fear from their vocabulary. So they pick and choose other words, like anxiety. Or scared. Nervous is another. Apprehensive. They dance all around. I have a theory – though others might call it hogwash. I’m convinced none of them are ashamed of being afraid – they know fear is a commonality. What they dread is where their fear might take them. Which will it be….fight or flight? There’s numerous wartime accounts of tough-talking, razzle-dazzle platoon sergeants and squad leaders – plus junior officers as well -- who went bonkers in their first battlefield encounter. Meantime, the near-sighted guy with glasses who barely passed his induction physical goes on to earn a Silver Star. I’ll never forget one POW sergeant. I asked him if being captured had affected his feeling of self-worth. He sat stiff as a statue for maybe two minutes. I could feel myself starting to squirm and so I went on to another question. On the next visit a week later, I no sooner sat down when he suddenly blurted out: ‘I feel that I failed. Failed the responsibility that I’d worked so hard to be entrusted with.’ And his face was all contorted -- awful. I instantly turned my gaze away. Why? Call it my own response to fear. Fear that I’d see tears running down his face, to our mutual embarrassment. So I cut and ran. Yeah – my eyes ran away to somewhere safer.”

You probably have certain favorites among the various interviews you’ve done. What makes them special--- or should I say, more memorable than the others?

“Well…there’s a couple that stand out…in part because of the response they gendered. One involved a gunner’s mate – the last man off the Hornet. He was a retired college professor – taught an electronics course. Though I think he missed his real calling – he should have been a drama coach. His ability to describe unfolding events was so graphic that I felt like I was standing right alongside him on the carrier’s flight deck, dodging bomb shrapnel and tripping over mutilated bodies. My other favorite was a Marine corporal. By pure chance, I stumbled across his obituary the other day – he passed in August of 2010, age 86. He was a dog handler, 3rd War Dog Platoon, and served on Guadalcanal, Guam and Iwo Jima. In addition to the number of times the dog saved his life and the lives of other Marines, the post-war adventures these two had together is something to marvel at. I thought at the time it would make a terrific movie – still do.”

How do you locate WW11 oral history candidates? Outside of nursing homes, they’re rather scarce these days.

“Mostly I stumble across them. I say stumble – actually I do keep an eye half-cocked. News stories around December 7 and the 4th of July and D-Day can provide good leads. I personally knew two Medal of Honor guys – one from WW11 and a marine from the Chosin Reservoir in Korea. The marine I met accidentally in a parking lot in Florida – spotted his MOH license plate. The other was a friend of a friend. It was great fun listening to their stories – not about the war, but post-war. They enjoyed a number of fantastic MOH privileges and seldom hesitated using them. MOH holders outrank and outflank everybody. Bumping colonels and even generals off military transport planes to get their seats seemed to be a favorite sport – though they admittedly liked to exaggerate as to the number. I’ve never interviewed a Coast Guardsman, though I worked at one time with a CG vet who happened across a couple German spies coming ashore on Long Island as he was walking his beach patrol at night. One that I really regret missing out on was a German immigrant named Krueger. Three years as a Panzer tank driver in Russia – three years in hell. What little I learned about him came from his daughter Renate, a friend of my wife’s. I tried every tactic --- even took him trout fishing which he dearly loved to do. But he just wouldn’t warm to me. And I waited too long back in eighty-seven with a Houston survivor, who barely made it to shore from the sinking cruiser and spent the rest of the war struggling to stay alive in Jap prison camps. Died in the Golden Nugget in Las Vegas in his sleep. I was a guest at the 52 Boats SubVets Memorial dedication in San Diego a while back. The place was crawling with smoke** boat vets, widows of vets, sons and daughters and grandchildren and great-grandchildren of vets. I was there with a buddy, just turned 90. He served aboard a fleet sub and is one of four surviving original crew members. Poor guy -- he tripped and fell hard enough to end up in the hospital and missed most of the dedication ceremony. I told him I was going to write a story about his headlong encounter with an enemy sidewalk and living to tell about it. He came back at me with: ‘Some darn fool in the crowd shouted – DIVE! DIVE! DIVE! So that’s what I did – I took a nosedive.’ A bit of mischievous humor here, but anchored to an ingrained reflex that every submariner had drilled into his head -- instant obedience to a given command. In other words, the difference between living and dying in a fleet submarine could sometimes be measured in a handful of seconds. That’s exactly how Commander Gilmore died – he sacrificed his own life to save the lives of his crew. And he had to make up his mind to do it in a matter of a few seconds.”

Have you ever interviewed a war lover, so-called?

“Nope, never. Though I know there’s a few out there. It’s a DNA or genes kind of thing. Descended from Viking warriors. (laughs) Gotta be.”

Is there wisdom to be gained by reading these accounts – a better understanding of ourselves, perhaps? I’m being a bit philosophical here.

“I’d only be making a wild guess, and you don’t want that. It all boils down to subjectivity. What appears to one reader as a brave and inspired act may well be perceived by another as plain reckless or even stupid. Sometimes it’s what they call a non-impulsive action – the mind goes totally blank, and they just do it. With one exception – front line medics. They’re the only soldiers on the battlefield charged with saving lives….and that means consciously exposing themselves to mortal danger again and again as they tend to the wounded. Their kind of repeated bravery is certainly worthy of study and reflection – and admiration. Beyond that – what you’re left with is luck. I’ve come to think of luck as a yardstick that’s measured in feet and inches and fractions – what’s commonly referred to in battle as close calls. Bullets and bombs and torpedoes… artillery and mortar fire….they all kill. But they can also save lives. A friend of mine carries a beat-up bullet on his key ring that a field surgeon dug out of his father’s hip. I speak here of the proverbial million dollar wound – the GI’s fast track ticket off the battlefield. Suddenly he’s removed from further danger by pure luck, and with his honor intact. The other three guys in his father’s reconnaissance patrol weren’t so lucky and left the battle site in body bags. But let’s take an even deeper look at luck – let’s up the ante. Say you’ve been wounded three times, returning voluntarily after each recovery to your platoon. That sort of thing happened more often than you’d imagine. Whew! – you’re one lucky guy. Then let’s say that on the very day Germany surrenders, you step on a schuh mine or get shot by a sniper – whatever -- and you’re dead. How’s that for irony! Your fabulous run of luck abandons you at the last minute – big time. Right? Wrong. Measured another way, you’re luck actually ran out when you weren’t killed the first time, thus avoiding the pain and suffering of two more wounds. See what I’m getting at? As events unfold, we tend to examine them retrospectively. That’s why I’m so taken by the repeated irony I spoke of previously. Makes me think of the fellow who was struck by lightning three different times, and survived each strike with only minor injuries. Was he lucky or unlucky? An equal dose of both, I’d say. Some years later he lost an arm and half a leg when the aluminum ladder he was moving made contact with an overhead power cable. My guess is he’s now at the point where he won’t even go near an electric razor.”

What do you think the war dead would have to say, if they could speak?

“Sheez – let’s not travel that road. Two gallons of bourbon later…”

I take it back --- that was dumb. Let me erase that…

“Mmmm…that’s OK, leave it be. I just remembered something. I can’t answer your question, but there’s some sailors who just might. They know all there is to know about a violent death. Google up ‘The Mess Cook.’ Write that down – the mess cook. And don’t forget your anti-fear pills – you’ll need them. Bring the full prescription and swallow them all. There’s more than enough water to wash them down where you’re going.”

* Korean war vet (USAF); European history college professor (retired).

**diesel powered fleet subs, as distinct from today’s nuclear driven.
* * ** *

Copyright © 2011 Tony Welch 

Written by Tony Welch. If you have questions or comments on this article, please contact Tony Welch at:
scriptony@hotmail.com.

About the author:
Tony Welch has recorded oral histories of WWII veterans in seven states. His interest in preserving first-person battlefield accounts began a half-century ago, when as a U.S. Navy journalist he began "picking the brains" of senior enlisted men. Says Welch: "If they had four or more hash marks on their sleeve and campaign ribbons on their chest, they were fair game."

Published online: 06/05/2011.

* Views expressed by contributors are their own and do not necessarily represent those of MHO.
© 2014 MilitaryHistoryOnline.com, LLC Contact Brian Williams at: militaryhistoryonline@hotmail.com